Severance Pay vs. Common Law Notice What Most People Miss
If you think severance pay equals full entitlement you may be leaving money behind
When employees are terminated in Canada, they are often told they are receiving severance pay. The number is presented clearly. The document looks formal. The language sounds complete.
What most employees do not realize is that severance pay under employment standards legislation is only one layer of entitlement.
In Canada, there is often a substantial gap between minimum statutory severance and common law reasonable notice. That gap can represent weeks or even months of additional compensation. Understanding it is the difference between accepting an offer at face value and evaluating it strategically.
What severance pay actually means under employment standards legislation
Severance pay is frequently used as a general term, but legally it has a specific meaning.
Employment standards legislation sets minimum protections. For federally regulated employees, the Canada Labour Code outlines notice and severance obligations. Most other employees are covered by provincial legislation. For example, the Ontario Ministry of Labour explains minimum termination pay and severance pay requirements under the Employment Standards Act.
These laws establish baseline protections.
They are designed to prevent exploitation. They are not designed to reflect the full economic consequences of job loss in every situation.
Minimum standards represent the legal floor, not the ceiling.
What common law reasonable notice really is
Common law reasonable notice is developed through court decisions rather than statute.
Unless your employment contract contains a valid and enforceable termination clause that clearly limits your entitlement, you are generally presumed to be entitled to reasonable notice at common law.
The Supreme Court of Canada confirmed in Machtinger v HOJ Industries Ltd that employment standards legislation creates minimum protections that cannot be contracted out of and that ambiguous termination clauses should be interpreted in favour of employees.
Courts assess reasonable notice based on contextual factors, including:
Length of service
Age
Position and seniority
Availability of comparable employment
There is no fixed formula. The assessment is individualized. In many cases, common law notice significantly exceeds statutory minimums.
The gap most employees overlook
Here is where the misunderstanding happens. An employer may present a severance offer that matches statutory minimums exactly. Because it complies with legislation, it appears legitimate and complete.
But compliance with legislation does not necessarily reflect full entitlement.
For example, an employee with ten years of service may receive ten weeks of statutory notice in some jurisdictions. Under common law principles, that same employee might be entitled to several months of compensation depending on age, role, and job market conditions.
Statistics Canada data shows that reemployment timelines vary significantly by industry and age group. Courts consider these real world factors when assessing reasonable notice.
The gap between minimum standards and common law notice is often where the most meaningful financial difference lies.
Why termination clauses matter so much
Everything often turns on the employment contract. If your contract contains a clear and enforceable termination clause that limits your entitlement to statutory minimums, your common law rights may be displaced.
However, many termination clauses are later found unenforceable because they:
Attempt to contract out of minimum standards
Are inconsistently drafted
Do not account for benefit continuation requirements
Conflict with severance pay obligations
When a clause is unenforceable, the employee may revert to common law reasonable notice.
A careful review of the termination clause is one of the most important steps before accepting a severance offer.
What is included in common law notice
Another common misconception is that severance covers salary only. Common law notice generally reflects total compensation, which may include:
Base salary
Bonuses and incentive pay
Commissions
Benefits continuation
Pension contributions
Other regular compensation elements
If a severance offer excludes variable compensation without clear explanation, it may not reflect full entitlement.
Understanding the composition of your compensation package is critical to evaluating whether the offer is complete.
Why employees accept less than they may be owed
Several factors contribute to under evaluation:
Pressure deadlines
Emotional shock following termination
Assumption that legislation equals full entitlement
Fear of conflict
Lack of clarity about legal framework
Employers often frame offers as enhanced or generous. Without context, those words feel reassuring.
But generous compared to what. If the comparison point is statutory minimums, the offer may appear generous. If the comparison point is potential common law exposure, the analysis may change.
Clarity replaces emotional framing with objective assessment.
Practical steps before signing a release
Before signing a severance agreement, consider the following:
Review your employment contract carefully
Confirm your length of service and compensation structure
Separate statutory minimum amounts from additional discretionary payments
Assess whether bonuses and benefits are properly included
Consider obtaining independent legal advice
A severance agreement typically includes a release. Once signed, it generally waives your right to pursue additional claims. Reversing that decision later is difficult.
An informed review protects you from permanently closing the gap.
Why this distinction affects your financial future
The difference between minimum standards and common law notice can materially impact:
Mortgage payments
Debt management
Retirement savings
Health benefit continuity
Job search flexibility
Statistics Canada consistently reports that income disruption significantly affects household financial stability.
Severance is not just a legal issue. It is a financial planning issue. Understanding the gap ensures you are making a decision based on full information rather than assumption.
Understanding the gap is the first step toward protecting your entitlement
The difference between severance pay and common law notice is not technical or academic. It is often the difference between accepting the minimum and securing what you are actually owed.
Employment standards legislation sets the floor. Common law reasonable notice may raise that floor significantly depending on your age, tenure, role, and the realities of the job market. The challenge is that employers are not required to explain that distinction to you. Once you sign a release, the opportunity to revisit that gap is usually gone.
Before accepting any severance offer, take the time to understand where your package sits on that spectrum. Separate minimum statutory entitlements from discretionary payments. Review your termination clause carefully. Assess whether your compensation has been fully accounted for. Most importantly, make your decision from a place of clarity rather than urgency.
Severance is not just a number on a page. It is your financial bridge to what comes next.
Severance Response Pack
Structured severance response and negotiation email drafts, written in a neutral, HR-safe tone.
CA$49 • Instant download • Canada-specific
Frequently asked questions about severance pay and common law notice in Canada
Is severance pay the same as reasonable notice?
No. Severance pay under employment standards legislation represents minimum statutory entitlements. Common law reasonable notice may result in significantly higher compensation unless a valid contract limits your rights.
Can my employer limit me to minimum standards only?
Yes, if your employment contract contains a clear and enforceable termination clause that fully complies with employment standards legislation. If the clause is invalid, you may revert to common law notice.
How do I know if my termination clause is enforceable?
Enforceability depends on precise wording and compliance with current legislation. Many clauses are later found invalid because they conflict with statutory minimum requirements.
Does common law notice include bonuses and benefits?
Often yes. Courts typically assess total compensation, not just base salary, when determining reasonable notice.
What is the safest way to evaluate my severance offer?
Separate statutory minimums from additional compensation, review your employment contract carefully, assess your leverage factors, and consider obtaining independent legal advice before signing any release.
